Electric VehiclesNegotiationProcurement

Should-Costing: How Automotive & EV Buyers Know What a Part Should Cost

Learn how should-costing helps automotive and EV buyers negotiate on facts. See a worked EV part example and build your own estimate with Voltbridge.

EV Industry Team
Oct 19, 2026

01-featured-should-cost-guide.png

Know what a part should cost before you negotiate

A supplier quotes ₹700 for a part. Is that a fair price? Without your own view of the cost, the only lever is to ask for a discount and hope. Should-costing replaces that guesswork with a bottom-up estimate built from materials, processing, overheads and a fair margin.

The method is proven. McKinsey calls should-costing the gold standard for hardware purchases at automotive companies. Inverto, a BCG company, reports that savings in its should-costing projects average 14%, depending on the components bought. Inverto also notes that the method pays off most where suppliers are few and parts are hard to swap — common in automotive and EV supply chains.

This guide explains how should-costing works, walks through a real example — an EV oil pump assembly made in India — and shows you how to build your own estimate with the Voltbridge Should-Cost Estimator.

What is should-costing?

Should-costing estimates what a part would cost if an efficient supplier made it with today's material prices, machine rates and a reasonable margin. You build the price up line by line, instead of taking a percentage off last year's invoice or the supplier's quote.

The question changes from "Can you do it cheaper?" to "What should this cost, and why is your price different?" That shift is what makes the method work in negotiations.

Five principles

  1. Find the cost drivers. Weight times material rate, cycle time times machine rate, labour, overheads. A die-cast housing is driven by the aluminium price; a wiring harness by labour hours.
  2. Compare line by line, not just the total. A quote can match your total and still hide an expensive line that another line offsets.
  3. Negotiate on facts. Ask why a specific line differs. A blanket discount request invites a blanket refusal.
  4. Feed findings back into design. An extra machining operation or a tight tolerance shows up as a cost line engineering can challenge.
  5. Keep the model current. Material prices, wages and machine rates move. Re-run the model when they do, before the supplier asks for a price increase.

Breaking down the cost of an EV part: a worked example

Our example is an EV oil pump assembly: an 850 g die-cast aluminium housing, CNC-machined and assembled with two ball bearings and four sintered magnets. Volume is 50,000 pieces a year over a six-year program, made in India. Its should-cost comes to ₹560.59 per piece (about $5.93 or €5.20).

02-cost-breakdown-ev-oil-pump.png

Every should-cost is built from the same seven sections. This is the structure of a sourcing price-breakdown sheet, and the one the Voltbridge tool uses.

SectionWhat it covers in this example₹ per pieceShare
A. Purchased parts2 ball bearings at ₹42, 4 magnets at ₹26188.0033%
B. Raw material850 g cast aluminium at ₹215/kg182.7533%
C. ProcessingDie casting (38 s), CNC milling (65 s), assembly (55 s, 2 operators): machine + labour time40.167%
D. MarkupsFactory overhead 15% of C; scrap 3%, SG&A 8% and profit 10% of A+B+C; 5% on bought-out parts and 2% on material105.3719%
E. Packaging3% of the cost subtotal15.493%
F. LogisticsFreight and handling, 4% of the cost subtotal20.654%
G. Tooling₹24.5 lakh of dies, fixtures and gauges spread over 3,00,000 lifetime pieces8.171%
Should-cost560.59100%

Three things stand out:

  • Two lines drive two-thirds of the cost. Bought-out parts and aluminium make up 66%. The magnet price and the aluminium rate matter far more than the assembly time.
  • Margins are visible, not hidden. SG&A and profit together are ₹73.96, or 13% of the price. You can see what the supplier earns and judge whether it is fair.
  • Tooling depends on volume. It adds only ₹8.17 a piece at 50,000 a year. If volume drops to 20,000 a year, the same tooling adds ₹20.42 a piece.

03-waterfall-should-cost-vs-quote.png

Now compare the supplier's quote of ₹700. The gap is ₹139.41 per piece, or 25%. At 50,000 pieces that is about ₹70 lakh a year — worth a structured conversation.

All rates in this example are indicative India market references from mid-2026. Use your own supplier and regional data for a real negotiation.

Why should-costing matters in supplier negotiations

Suppliers know their own costs; buyers usually don't. Should-costing closes that information gap, so the conversation moves from positions to facts.

It turns a price fight into a line-by-line discussion. Here is an illustrative exchange based on our example:

Buyer: "Our model puts aluminium at about ₹183 a piece: 850 g at ₹215 a kilo. Your quote implies closer to ₹230. What are we missing?"

Supplier: "We're using a premium alloy, and our yield on this die is lower than you assume."

Buyer: "Can we check whether a standard die-casting alloy meets the spec? And what yield does the new die give?"

The buyer never asked for a discount. Both sides now work on two concrete levers: alloy grade and yield.

It finds savings that matter. Inverto puts the average saving from its should-costing projects at 14%. McKinsey found a 10–30% gap between the best offer and the should-cost in automotive software. In our example, the gap is 25%.

It builds better supplier relationships. A should-cost includes a fair margin; our example keeps a 10% profit. Suppliers see that you are not trying to squeeze them below cost, only to understand the price.

How to use it in the room

Inverto's practical advice is worth following:

  • Don't open with your number. Go through the cost blocks with the supplier one by one, and share your view as you go.
  • Bring an engineer. Someone who can discuss cycle times and process choices at a technical level.
  • Check overheads closely. Overhead allocation is a small cost pool, but often the biggest saving in percentage terms.
  • Judge the margin against peers. Compare it with similar-sized companies in the same industry.

Build your own should-cost with Voltbridge

The Voltbridge Should-Cost Estimator turns this method into a guided form. Every amount updates as you type, and the example above is preloaded so you can see how it works.

04-should-cost-tool-overview.png

  1. Describe the part. Enter the part name, annual volume, program life and manufacturing region. Work in rupees, dollars or euros; exchange rates are shown and refreshed daily.
  2. Build the cost, section by section. Add bought-out parts, raw materials and processing steps. The built-in machine-rate calculator derives a machine's hourly rate from its price, power use, maintenance and floor space. Then set markups, packaging, logistics and tooling.
  3. Check the supplier's quote. Enter the quoted price to see the gap in rupees and percent. Compare the same part costed in India, China, Mexico and Europe side by side.
  4. Export and negotiate. Download the breakdown as an Excel file with live formulas, or as a PDF, and take it into the supplier conversation.

05-should-cost-tool-results.png

06-how-to-use-should-cost-tool.png

Coming soon: an automatic estimate from a drawing. You'll upload a PDF, STEP or DWG file, and the tool will pre-fill the material, weight and process steps for you to review. It isn't available yet; today you enter the details manually.

Common challenges, and how to handle them

Should-costing is only as good as its inputs and the way you use it. These are the hurdles teams hit most often.

ChallengeWhat helps
Missing or outdated dataStart from published material prices and machine-hour rates, keep them current, and ask suppliers to confirm cycle times.
Not enough timeModel your highest-spend parts first. A tool with ready rate libraries cuts each model from days to minutes.
Supplier pushbackShare your logic, not just your number. Agree early that a fair margin is part of the price.
Complex assembliesCost each sub-assembly separately, then add them up. Involve engineering for process assumptions.
Volatile material pricesLink material lines to a price index and re-run the model when it moves.

Start with one part

You don't need a cost-engineering department to begin. Pick one high-spend part with a quote on your desk, build its should-cost, and walk the supplier through it section by section. The gap you find, and the reasons behind it, will show you where to go next.

Open the Voltbridge Should-Cost Estimator →

Looking for alternative suppliers once you know the target price? Browse verified Indian EV component suppliers on Voltbridge.

Frequently asked questions

What is a should-cost analysis?

A bottom-up estimate of what a part should cost, built from its materials, processing, overheads, margins, packaging, logistics and tooling. Buyers use it to judge whether a supplier's quote is fair.

How is a should-cost different from a supplier's price breakdown?

A price breakdown is the supplier's own account of its costs. A should-cost is your independent estimate. Comparing the two, line by line, shows where the quote is high.

When should procurement use should-costing?

For high-spend parts, new sourcing decisions, price-increase requests, and parts with few alternative suppliers.

How accurate is a should-cost estimate?

As accurate as its inputs. Treat it as a well-founded target for negotiation, not an exact price, and refine it with the supplier's cycle times and your own market data.

Can I get a should-cost from a drawing?

Not yet. Automatic estimates from PDF, STEP and DWG drawings are coming to the Voltbridge Should-Cost Estimator. Today you enter the part details manually.

Sources

  1. Inverto, a BCG company — Fair procurement prices through Should Costing
  2. McKinsey & Company, 2020 — Software 'should costing': A new procurement tool for automotive companies
  3. McKinsey & Company, 2018 — Find cost opportunities with today's should-cost analysis
  4. Worked example: Voltbridge Should-Cost Estimator sample part, India market reference rates, mid-2026.
E

EV Industry Team

Our team of industry experts bringing you the latest insights.